by Clarence Oxford
Los Angeles CA (SPX) Apr 22, 2025
A newly published study by SETI Institute researchers suggests that the irregularity of certain meteor showers arises not from chaotic planetary influences but from the subtle, yet consequential, motion of the Sun itself. The findings, presented in the journal Icarus, offer a fresh perspective on the long-term behavior of comets and their meteoroid trails.
"Contrary to popular conception, everything in the solar system does not orbit the Sun," explained Stuart Pilorz, lead author and SETI Institute scientist. "Rather, the Sun and planets all orbit their common center of mass, known to scientists as the solar system barycenter."
This center of mass, or barycenter, wobbles in response to the gravitational pull of massive planets, primarily Jupiter and Saturn. While often ignored in modeling comet behavior, this subtle motion of the Sun can significantly alter the trajectory of long-period comets that swing into the inner solar system every few centuries.
Long-period comets spend most of their orbits in the distant reaches of the solar system, where they feel the gravitational influence of the barycenter more than the Sun. As they plunge inward, close to Jupiter's orbit or within, the Sun's gravity dominates. During these near-Sun passes, comets release particles that form meteoroid streams. These streams are initially thin, with low probability of intersecting Earth, but they evolve unpredictably over time.
Meteor astronomer Peter Jenniskens, co-author of the study and affiliated with both the SETI Institute and NASA Ames Research Center, recognized that these streams follow complex patterns influenced by the Sun's motion. "Back in 1995, our field was in its infancy and many thought that predicting when these streams would cause a meteor shower on Earth was as hard as predicting the weather," he noted.
Jenniskens observed that meteoroid streams appeared to drift in and out of Earth's orbit, matching the Sun's wobble caused by the planetary orbits of Jupiter and Saturn. He successfully predicted a return shower when the giant planets reached specific orbital positions. A brief but intense meteor display over Spain confirmed his calculations.
This wobble operates on cycles of approximately 12 and 30 years, reflecting the orbital periods of Jupiter and Saturn, respectively. Over time, these oscillations compound, producing a roughly 60-year rhythm in the Sun's position and velocity relative to the barycenter.
The study's core insight is that meteoroids receive small but cumulative changes in speed and direction due to gravitational interactions during solar close-encounters. "A principal result of this study," said Pilorz, "was merely noticing that if we keep track of the fact that the Sun is in motion about the barycenter, we see that most of what actually causes the comets and meteoroids to disperse is that they each pick up a gravitational boost or braking from the moving Sun as they pass close to it."
This effect resembles a gravitational slingshot, often used to adjust spacecraft trajectories. But as Pilorz emphasized, "the train has to be moving for it to work" - and in this analogy, the Sun is that moving train.
Once inside Jupiter's orbit, meteoroids shift from being governed by the barycenter to being dominated by the Sun's gravitational field. Each time a meteoroid interacts with the Sun during its close passage, it receives a slightly different gravitational "kick" depending on the Sun's position and speed at that moment. This leads to divergence within the stream.
The researchers identified two key points where these kicks occur: when the Sun begins to dominate as the meteoroid approaches, and when the object transitions back to barycentric influence as it recedes. Each transition subtly alters the meteoroid's inclination and orbital node.
Over time, these staggered kicks cause the stream to warp and spread. "We're used to telling ourselves that a comet's motion changes randomly due to a series of complex perturbations from the planets," said Pilorz. "That isn't wrong, but if we recall that the Sun also orbits the barycenter, the explanation becomes much simpler."
While planetary gravity still governs overall torque and long-term precession, especially between the orbits of Jupiter and Saturn, the study shows that accounting for the Sun's motion adds critical clarity to the apparent chaos of meteoroid stream behavior.
Research Report:Sun Close-Encounter model of long-period comet and Meteoroid Orbit Stochastic Evolution
Related Links
SETI Institute
Asteroid and Comet Mission News, Science and Technology